Nascrag Feedback
Normal
Small
Posted by nascragman

Hi there!  NascragMan here.  I know I've been fairly absent from these new forums, but often life intrudes on our fun.  It didn't stop us from running the tournament though, and we had a great time.

Does anybody have any feedback?  Positive or otherwise :-) ?

We only get better when we hear from you.

What do people think of the 9 pm - 1 am slot?  When I was a player it was my favorite (quieter in the hall).  But they've been more lightly attended in recent years.

Did you like the character mix?  What are we missing?  Do we need Bards?  Monks?  Druids?  What do you like to play?

Feel free to speak your mind.

 

Normal
Small
Posted by helenbb

Last year was my first GenCon and I've played (and heartily enjoyed) NASCRAG both years. Generally I pick the timeslot that works best for me (i.e. fits in best around other events) but I'm not a night person, so 9 pm to 1 am would be waaaay too late for me. At first I thought you said 9 am to 1 pm and I was all over that! 

Bards are my favorite character to play, because I love singing. I ended up having a bard personality with the robots in the finals this year and was glad I got the chance to sing. Of course, I also play a bard in True Dungeon and go around singing at the top of my lungs, so you can see that this is my *thing*.

One thing that's great about NASCRAG is the interesting characters that allow for fun roleplaying. A man who is a parrot, a zombie elf, a talking shrunken head, a dwarf who is obsessed with blowing things up... these are meaty characters! A party consisting of a fighter, a cleric, a rogue, a wizard + 2 others is dull. I love the personalities NASCRAG provides, and I hope that this will continue with the next adventure.

I would say that my biggest complaints are things that are difficult to solve. First is the noise. It's often difficult to hear the GM over the noise in the hall. I don't think there's much you can do about that. The second is being part of an incomplete group. I was a single who joined up with 4 other players, but we did not have a 6th for either round and had to have someone conscripted. This meant that both times we were the last ones to start, which put us at a significant disadvantage and was a little stressful, especially in the finals. If there were some way to be able to play with a team of 4 or 5 that would be terrific and helpful for the 'nearly complete' groups.

But even leaving NASCRAG just as it is, I want to continue to play every GenCon I attend! So thank you for the time and effort you all put into running the event.

Normal
Small
Posted by nascragman

We've seriously considered going with an optional 7th character and then either taking the average score of the individual players or dropping the lowest.  The 7th player would make it easier for the 5 man team to fill out.  People come to GenCon with friends and significant others.  So we get lots of pairs and threesomes.

The problem, of course, is that the 7th player adds additional resources.  At very least hit points and an extra POV on puzzles.  And dropping the lowest score would give a 7 man team a definite scoring advantage.

The best answer, of course, is to like us on Facebook and post there to fill out your team ahead of time

Normal
Small
Posted by bithlord

As one of the four that Helen joined up with this year, anything that would make filling teams easier would be awesome.  But, my BIGGEST request would be to have the same judges we had this year, every year [that's a joke, i know that won't happen].  Seriously, they both did an amazing job and I can't thank them enough.

Our team was Something Witty and Clever, so if you want to pass on our sincerest thanks to the two judges we had we would much appreciate it.

Side note -- as is our unfortunate habit, we missed the middle year of this arc.  Is there any way to acquire it now?

Edit:  Oh yea, real feedback.  Ummm...

I don't care about character classes -- to be honest, I've never payed attention to it on the sheet.  The real meat is the background and who the characters are.  I've generally found that trying to "play the class" is different from, and not as good as trying to "play the character". 

The 9PM - 1Am slot.  Yea, it's not happening for our team.  The 7-11 on Saturday for round to is just about at our limit.  We tried 9-1 two years, and both times at about 11 we just crashed, and crashed hard.  But, if there's enough teams to like it, keep it going.  For us, 5-9 is always going to be optimum, unless you did a 7-11 time for a prelim round.

Normal
Small
Posted by nascragman

Contact Nascrag@gmail.org about getting copies of older events.

So, if we switched to 1-4 and 7-11 for our Round 1 that would be better?

Just, spitballing ideas here.

Normal
Small
Posted by bithlord nascragman

nascragman wrote:
Contact Nascrag@gmail.org about getting copies of older events.
So, if we switched to 1-4 and 7-11 for our Round 1 that would be better?
Just, spitballing ideas here.

I can't speak for any teams but my own, but man... we'd murder people for a 7-11 timeslot.

Seriously, who do you want us to murder? 

Normal
Small
Posted by nascragman

No murder required.  that would be 1-5 and 7-11, though.  I mis-typed above

Normal
Small
Posted by nascragman

oops, i booted the contact info there, didn't I.  Nascrag@gmail.com not .org.

Normal
Small
Posted by helenbb

I contacted NASCRAG and tried using the address you posted. When it didn't work, I just used the contact form on the website and it worked out just fine. So that's always an option too. ;-)

This topic is locked. New posts cannot be added.