What do you think of the gaming groups?
1
1
Normal
Small
Posted by keppy

I run games with one of the gaming groups and I am just curious what people think of them? Do you look for specific groups? Do you avoid groups? Which groups are your favorites?  

Just curious and thought I would take an unofficial survey.

 

Normal
Small
Posted by parody

For the most part I don't pay attention to whether an event is attached to a group.  Just because I enjoy one event run by a GM who happens to be a member of a group doesn't mean I'm going to automatically like anything else the group runs or even other events run by that specific GM.

There are a couple of groups whose events I avoid, whether due to multiple poor experiences and knowing they organize many similar events or due to them being focused on a type of event I don't enjoy.  Those tend to be highly personal, though.

Normal
Small
Posted by daveculp

The only group I look for is Game Base 7 and actively avoid games run by them.  I had a very bad experience in a Pathfinder game a few years ago run by them and decided I would never go to another game run by them.

Normal
Small
Posted by alans

I like Rogue Judges - their GMs are enthusiastic and what they have described, they delivered, when I've played in their events.
 

Normal
Small
Posted by wjmacguffin

I've only played in two gaming group events, and that's more than enough for me. Both occasions were full of private jokes, interruptions by others, nonsensical GM adjudications, gaming nepotism, and in one case, pressure to purchase a game book a member had written.

I'm sure other groups are just peachy, but I don't feel like risking it. I've had a LOT more fun heading into games with random folks.  

Normal
Small
Posted by mightyllamas

The gaming group is a big factor in my decision making.  If I enjoyed playing a game with a group, odds are I'll probably enjoy other games put on by them.   In particular, I've found that Infinite Imaginations Inc. tends to run the type of games I like to play, and has GM's that I like.  The way my schedule worked out this year I think I ended up with my entire Saturday in their games :)
 

Normal
Small
Posted by keppy wjmacguffin

wjmacguffin wrote:
I've only played in two gaming group events, and that's more than enough for me. Both occasions were full of private jokes, interruptions by others, nonsensical GM adjudications, gaming nepotism, and in one case, pressure to purchase a game book a member had written.
I'm sure other groups are just peachy, but I don't feel like risking it. I've had a LOT more fun heading into games with random folks.  

I have been with the same group for about 20 years, and I admit one of the thing I see from within are the tendencies for in jokes and nepotism amongst some of the GMs. It rather annoys me as my goal is to run something that brings in new people instead of catering to people who already like our games. On the bright side I do not believe anyone in our group has ever hawked someone else book so at least that is a plus. :P
 

Normal
Small
Posted by deltafox65

Interesting thread. I just made up a gaming group name for tracking purposes on the games I'm running and try to pressure some other guys from my game group to run a few events under that banner. I have never thought about the negatives of this that have been pointed out above. I personally like seeing gaming groups because it sometimes is my deciding factor on what I play based off two events at the same time slot. Although DM factors first I do take groups into consideration. In my case MU Skulls is running a nightmares game that peaked my interest because they are running it. I've enjoyed past games ran by them in Cthulhu games and assume we have similar taste so I thought "might as well". 

Normal
Small
Posted by wjmacguffin

If you get a critical mass of gamer friends in the same event (or sometimes, in the same room), then you run the risk of those friends treating the con game like their Saturday night basement game. It's probably not anything they're even aware of. Get the same people together, and they hit the old behavioral ruts. 

That's why I like gaming with randos. It forces me to stay away from those ruts, too. 

Normal
Small
Posted by rbree wjmacguffin

wjmacguffin wrote:
If you get a critical mass of gamer friends in the same event (or sometimes, in the same room), then you run the risk of those friends treating the con game like their Saturday night basement game. It's probably not anything they're even aware of. Get the same people together, and they hit the old behavioral ruts. 
That's why I like gaming with randos. It forces me to stay away from those ruts, too. 
I think the OP is referring to groups that run games not play in games together.  I apologize if I miss read what you're saying.   Most of the groups I've run in or run for don't have group members playing in the games run unless they need a filler or two to reach the game minimum, so we don't have to cancel it.  And I'm not sure how it goes with other groups but the Exile Games Group only see each other at Cons at don't game together on a regular basis because we are spread from Seattle to Baltimore.

 

Normal
Small
Posted by ifdirector

I always seek out Nascrag for the fun they have in creating and running the module and then the groups of people who come back year after year to play.

Normal
Small
Posted by deltafox65

NASCRAG is a perfect example of a great gaming group which either attracts or deters interest in the game they are running.  I have played in one of their events because of the mass hype that surrounds their sign in.  They put on a first class show and the amount of work they put into these events show with the product you receive.  Puzzles, role play, story line.  With this being said though, I have never signed up for another and probably will not in the future because the overall humor is not a match for mine.  Everything about their game is top notch though and I would suggest others to give it a try to see if it matches up with your personal taste.  So I guess I am just chiming in again to say how the gaming group option really helps my game selections either for a group or a subtle pass on a game.  I usually even look at my wish list after completed to make sure I have at least one new gaming group every year to see where they fall on my preference of style.  So it's a big thumbs up from me on gaming groups. On a side note if anyone has specific groups that really stand out for them, I would be interested to hear about.  I plan on trying to find an Infinite Imaginations Inc. game and/or a Rogue Judges to see where they fall on my eclectic style barometer.

Normal
Small
Posted by wjmacguffin rbree

rbree wrote:
wjmacguffin wrote:
If you get a critical mass of gamer friends in the same event (or sometimes, in the same room), then you run the risk of those friends treating the con game like their Saturday night basement game. It's probably not anything they're even aware of. Get the same people together, and they hit the old behavioral ruts. 
That's why I like gaming with randos. It forces me to stay away from those ruts, too. 
I think the OP is referring to groups that run games not play in games together.  I apologize if I miss read what you're saying.   Most of the groups I've run in or run for don't have group members playing in the games run unless they need a filler or two to reach the game minimum, so we don't have to cancel it.  And I'm not sure how it goes with other groups but the Exile Games Group only see each other at Cons at don't game together on a regular basis because we are spread from Seattle to Baltimore. 

Both groups I experienced had friends playing in games. Not sure if they were official group members or just buddies, but that point was moot. Even if a group restricts their members to running games, if they're all in the same room at nearby tables, you run this risk. 

Then again, it's just a risk. My experiences =/= yours. 

Normal
Small
Posted by brotherbock wjmacguffin

wjmacguffin wrote:
rbree wrote:
wjmacguffin wrote:
If you get a critical mass of gamer friends in the same event (or sometimes, in the same room), then you run the risk of those friends treating the con game like their Saturday night basement game. It's probably not anything they're even aware of. Get the same people together, and they hit the old behavioral ruts. 
That's why I like gaming with randos. It forces me to stay away from those ruts, too. 
I think the OP is referring to groups that run games not play in games together.  I apologize if I miss read what you're saying.   Most of the groups I've run in or run for don't have group members playing in the games run unless they need a filler or two to reach the game minimum, so we don't have to cancel it.  And I'm not sure how it goes with other groups but the Exile Games Group only see each other at Cons at don't game together on a regular basis because we are spread from Seattle to Baltimore. 

Both groups I experienced had friends playing in games. Not sure if they were official group members or just buddies, but that point was moot. Even if a group restricts their members to running games, if they're all in the same room at nearby tables, you run this risk. Then again, it's just a risk. My experiences =/= yours. 

Our GMs play in each others games, but we don't play favorites. In fact, we are most often there to play the characters no one else wants, whatever is left over after the people not in our group have their characters. I'm just as likely to be playing a King as a stable boy, or girl, in any particular event. If we're full, we'll sometimes just help out as NPCs or assistant GMs. 

But our GMs write good games, and there are 25-35 people, why wouldn't I want to play in their games? :) 

Normal
Small
Posted by yog-sothoth in jersey

I think the gaming group or event organizer matters a lot, especially for RPG or LARP.  I won't sign up for an event unless I've researched the group and other people have had good experiences in the past.  

I've personally had a great experience with: 

Novus Ordo Seclorum
You Too Can Cthulhu (is that the same as Novus?)
MU Skulls
Iocane Productions
Rogue Judges

Normal
Small
Posted by rbree yog-sothoth in jersey

yog-sothoth in jersey wrote:
I think the gaming group or event organizer matters a lot, especially for RPG or LARP.  I won't sign up for an event unless I've researched the group and other people have had good experiences in the past.  
I've personally had a great experience with: 
Novus Ordo Seclorum
You Too Can Cthulhu (is that the same as Novus?)
MU Skulls
Iocane Productions
Rogue Judges
YTC and Novus are different groups...  but I think a few people may overlap.
 

Normal
Small
Posted by brotherbock yog-sothoth in jersey

yog-sothoth in jersey wrote:
I think the gaming group or event organizer matters a lot, especially for RPG or LARP.  I won't sign up for an event unless I've researched the group and other people have had good experiences in the past.  
I've personally had a great experience with: 
Novus Ordo Seclorum
You Too Can Cthulhu (is that the same as Novus?)
MU Skulls
Iocane Productions
Rogue Judges

Iocane is legit, absolutely. Their BSG larp was great, I'm upset I missed it last year. A ship needs it's security chief! They are great players too, we (BYOV) hit each other's games a lot :) I've always heard good things about Skulls, YTCC, and Rogue Judges too. Been around a long time with good word of mouth.  

Normal
Small
Posted by yog-sothoth in jersey brotherbock

brotherbock wrote:
yog-sothoth in jersey wrote:
I think the gaming group or event organizer matters a lot, especially for RPG or LARP.  I won't sign up for an event unless I've researched the group and other people have had good experiences in the past.  
I've personally had a great experience with: 
Novus Ordo Seclorum
You Too Can Cthulhu (is that the same as Novus?)
MU Skulls
Iocane Productions
Rogue Judges

Iocane is legit, absolutely. Their BSG larp was great, I'm upset I missed it last year. A ship needs it's security chief! They are great players too, we (BYOV) hit each other's games a lot :) I've always heard good things about Skulls, YTCC, and Rogue Judges too. Been around a long time with good word of mouth.  

I hear great things about BYOV! I need to try one of your events! 

Normal
Small
Posted by ryvre

I pick my larps based on the group running it more than the game itself.  I love Iocane, Mu Skulls, and BYOV!  There are some other larp groups that I know aren't my style, so I avoid them.  Even if the game sounds right up my alley, I won't have fun with certain play styles.

Normal
Small
Posted by pezkat

Another vote for Rogue Judges and one for Flight in the Skies Society.  For boardgamers you know there are trustworthy GMs and sometimes the flavor/type of games they generally run, so I always try to check our their listings.

This topic is locked. New posts cannot be added.
1
1